🎂 Craving Italian Cream Cake? Conway Residents Name Favorite Bakery
It started with a sweet question:
“Where can I get a really good Italian cream cake in town?”
What followed was a flood of delicious suggestions, as locals chimed in with their favorite bakeries, custom cake makers, and even tips for ordering in advance. From family-owned storefronts to home-based bakers, Conway has no shortage of places to satisfy that rich, coconut-pecan craving.
🏆 Top Picks for Italian Cream Cake in Conway
1. PattiCakes Bakery
📍 PattiCakes on Facebook
This long-time local favorite received the most love in the comments. Known for its rotating case of desserts and custom cake orders, many residents say it’s their go-to for Italian cream—especially around the holidays.
“Their Italian cream cake is heavenly. Moist, rich, and not too sweet!”
“Order ahead—it goes fast!”
2. Julie’s Sweet Shoppe & Bakery
📍 Julie’s Website
A crowd-pleaser on both taste and customer service, Julie’s is known for its scratch-made cakes and southern desserts. Multiple residents said they’ve had success getting Italian cream cake by special request.
“Call them a few days early—they’ll usually make it fresh.”
3. SugarDumplin’s Custom Cakes
📍 SugarDumplin’s on Facebook
Specializing in custom orders, SugarDumplin’s is a popular choice for weddings and birthdays—but they’ll also do a mean Italian cream cake if you ask.
“Best cake I’ve ever had—hands down. Worth the custom order.”
🧁 Honorable Mentions & Home Bakers
Several Conway locals also recommended:
- @BakedByBreeAR – A home baker known for custom flavors and fast turnaround.
- Ed’s Custom Cakes – A newer name with glowing early reviews.
- Sam’s Club – Surprisingly, some residents say the Italian cream cake here is “pretty dang good in a pinch.”
💡 Tips for Getting the Good Stuff
- Call ahead: Most bakeries don’t keep Italian cream cake in the case daily—it’s often made by request.
- Order a slice if possible: PattiCakes and Julie’s occasionally offer slices on Fridays or weekends.
- Book early for holidays: Thanksgiving, Easter, and Christmas are peak Italian cream cake times.
🍰 Final Bite
Whether you’re celebrating something special or just giving in to a sweet tooth, Conway has plenty of ways to get your Italian cream cake fix. With recipes steeped in southern tradition and bakers who know their craft, the city’s dessert scene doesn’t disappoint.